In memory of “In Flanders Fields”

I feel a strong but sort of irrational connection to John McCrae, the Canadian artilleryman, doctor and poet who left us “In Flanders Fields” and the poppy as a symbol of remembrance.  As a boy I spent two years in John McCrae Elementary School in Windsor.  That school has been gone now for about three decades, demolished, a casualty of changing demographics, and replaced with apparently childless houses.  But I have so many vignettes of childhood memory from my time at John McCrae in the early seventies . . .

But what I’m writing about now  is a very nice little volume I picked up a few months ago: a 1919 edition of In Flanders Fields and Other Poems by Lieut. -Col. John McCrae, M.D. with An Essay in Character by Sir Andrew MacPhail. I’m quite sure the text is available online and as publish on demand — neither, of course, a substitute for a century old hardcover copy — and I would recommend a reading.  “In Flanders Fields” is the finest poem in the collection, although I would single out “Slumber Songs” and “Mine Host” for attention, the first a pair of lullabies for a world at it’s end, longing for rest, and the other a brief journey to the Underworld without return.  “Disarmament”, like “In Flanders Fields” is a poetic suggestion that the work of soldiers is not finished, here clearly stated:

“If ye have righted all the wrongs of earth
Lay by the sword! Its work and ours is done.”

Looking at the poems back across a century and its horrible wars is fascinating. McCrae stood at the jagged and shattered meeting place of two worlds.  He, around forty years old, was the product of a quiet, structured colony of old, ordered imperial Europe. As he stood with his artillery company he looked out across the morass of opposing trenches and no man’s land at a future chaos. The world we live in today, chaotic in its own way, is in no way visible to McCrae. His poems are of complete loss, of Death being the only hope for Rest.

Attached to the poems, indeed, making up most of the book, is Sir Andrew’s “Essay in Character”. The “Essay” is made up largely of McCrae’s own writing, letters home to his mother for the most part.  Here we see McCrae valiantly maintaining the old imagination of war as a bit of a boxing match between gentlemen with a cup of tea in the evening. But the image cannot be maintained. The big guns are firing constantly, farmhouses are shattered and burning, in a world made of mud, noise and the screams of wounded men and horses. McCrae’s worlds, both the old order and the chaos of the trenches, are foreign lands to us. On the one hand we have no illusions of the nobility of any social class, and on the other, war today is something very different from the artillery duels and routine poison gas attacks on the trenches of the Great War.

In the poems and the Essay we see the decay and destruction of the old order in the mind and body of a single man.  McCrae was a brilliant man, a great physician, an inspiring teacher, a talented artist and poet and by all accounts an exceptional soldier and officer. Watching his struggle to remain cheerful, to encourage family at home, to send notes to children is painful. He constantly writes of his horse and his dogs who seem such a great comfort to him.  But, as his poems and MacPhail tell us, McCrae’s inner world is no longer a place of sunshine and pleasant company.  Like shattered Europe, McCrae sees only chaos and death.

When Death comes for John McCrae it is an almost pathetic contrast to the horrifying convulsions which destroyed the old order. McCrae’s is no heroic death in battle, no titanic struggle.  A telegram dated January 27th, 1918 declares McCrae to be seriously ill with pneumonia. The next day another announces his death that morning. On the 18th he had been healthy and preparing to accept a major promotion. No bang. No wimper. Just a rapid whithering to the Rest of which he so often wrote.

The Great War produced many works describing the great historical, social and psychic break that conflict became. I would suggest that In Flanders Fields, although — or perhaps because — it is cobbled together from disparate bits in different hands, deserves a place in the canon of great works on the Great War.

6 comments on “In memory of “In Flanders Fields”

  1. McCrae war poetry says:

    Read his The Anxious Dead of 1917 in
    conjunction with In Flanders Fields…

  2. McCrae war poetry says:

    “.. till the dead men hear/ Above their heads the legions pressing on:
    (These fought their fight in time of bitter fear/ And died not knowing how the day had gone.)…..
    Tell them, O guns, that we have heard their call/That we have sworn, and will not turn aside,
    That we will onward till we win or fall,
    That we will keep the faith for which they died.”
    Surely he repeats the message of the earlier work – keep up the fight – with the poignant reminder that the Fallen died without even knowing which side was victorious. Peace is not on his mind, but not quitting.

    • I took the final stanza as a hope for a time of peace:

      Bid them be patient, and some day, anon,
      They shall feel earth enwrapt in silence deep;
      Shall greet, in wonderment, the quiet dawn,
      And in content may turn them to their sleep.

      • McCrae war poetry says:

        Pushing on to achieve victory is surely more on the mind of those on the battlefield than the cessation of hostilities. Raised during the Second WW
        with kin overseas, we did not talk of peace- “at any price”- but not giving up in the face of casuatlies eg the Dieppe Raid.
        “Went the Day well ? We died and never knew” is echoed here.

      • Yes, to all you say, but, again, the final stanza surely references a future cessation of hostilities.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s